The Comic Book Time Machine
Exploring comic books past and present
The Comic Book Time Machine
Navigation
  • About
  • Podcast
  • Support
    • Amazon
    • My Comic Shop
  • Other Podcasts
You are here: Home › Ben › The SUPERMAN/BATMAN vs ALIEN/PREDATOR Dark Horse/DC Crossover Series – review and reading order

The SUPERMAN/BATMAN vs ALIEN/PREDATOR Dark Horse/DC Crossover Series – review and reading order

December 24, 2020 | Filed under: Ben, Crossover, What If/Elseworlds

REVIEW OF THE CROSSOVER SERIES

The first cover in the series, a masterpiece in using the iconic title characters

Recently, I used curbside pickup at one of my local comic shops (as detailed in this episode of the podcast) and as I wracked my brain trying to remember what they had in the store that I’d been wanting to read, I remembered the DC/Dark Horse crossover collections I’d passed over a few times over the last few years. Specifically, the Batman/Alien collection and the Batman/Predator collection. As I started digging deeper into the set of crossover collections, I realized there was a possible Elseworlds style alternate universe in which the Alien and Predator species (and franchise) existed in a DC Universe (if not THE DC universe). Starting with Batman vs. Predator in 1991 and Superman/Aliens in 1995, the two biggest heroes from DC took on the two biggest alien creatures in all of the “horror sci-fi” genre many times, culminating in the long winded title Superman and Batman Verses Alien and Predator (2007). Along the way, they were joined by other heroes, including a Justice League story with the Predator and Green Lantern verses the Xenomorphs.

But what I really wanted to know as I looked into things was “are they connected?” Already familiar with the three Batman vs, Predator series and knowing they were connected by referencing each other and building on each other, I had to know. Was S&B vs A&P a true culmination of a couple decades of story? Or was it just a cool, big idea to end a publishing relationship on?

The answer to the question above? Yes. It’s a little bit of both. As the series continues, they do reference the events in the previous chapters. However, each story tends to stand on its own (except when referencing an earlier chapter in a direct sequel). While obviously there is no over arching plan, there are through-lines and themes.

The cover of the final issue in the series

The primary themes and through-lines come from what I love about this series at its core. They explore the core of the titles characters as they are pushed to deal with an alien species: one, the Aliens, ruled by the ultimate in natural selection; the other, the Predators, ruled by a code of honor that is alien to us but understandable.

And so you have Batman, detective that he is, not just figuring out that alien hunters are killing people in Gotham, but also figuring out their honor system.

And you have Superman, dealing with the idea that the Xenomorphs, while killers, are also an alien race that lives in our universe and as such are they life to be valued?

And you have Darkseid, using the Xenomorphs as the weapons they were created to be.

There are ups and there are downs, but the entire series, taken as a whole, has some value when you do take it as a whole. The build up, from Batman verses a single Predator in the first chapter to Batman and Superman teaming up to take on a secluded branch of the Predators who have developed their own code of honor in the final chapter, made for some fun reading for me.

I plan to read this series again in the near future, and possibly do a podcast episode (or a couple) when I do.

Perhaps the most iconic cover in the bunch

READING ORDER

Because of the way they are collected, it is easy and reasonably affordable to get the entire “Aliens/Predator/Justice League” universe.

Here are all of the DC Comics/Dark Horse collections:
DC Comics/Dark Horse Comics: Batman vs. Predator
DC Comics/Dark Horse Comics: Aliens
Dark Horse Comics/DC Comics: Superman
DC Comics/Dark Horse Comics: Justice League Vol. 1
Dark Horse Comics/DC Comics: Justice League Volume 2

But also because of the way they are collected, it is NOT easy to read them in the order they were created. And so, whether you have to bounce around from one collected edition to another OR bounce round from one back issue set to another, here is the reading order I have created.

BATMAN VS PREDATOR (1991)
Collected in DC/Dark Horse: Batman Vs. Predator.

BATMAN VS PREDATOR II: BLOODMATCH (1993)
Collected in DC/Dark Horse: Batman Vs. Predator.

SUPERMAN/ALIENS (1995)
Collected in Dark Horse Comics/DC Comics: Superman.

BATMAN VS PREDATOR III: BLOOD TIES (1997)
Collected in DC/Dark Horse: Batman Vs. Predator.

BATMAN/ALIENS (1997)
Collected in DC Comics/Dark Horse Comics: Aliens.

SUPERMAN VS PREDATOR (2000)
Collected in DC Comics/Dark Horse Comics: Justice League Vol. 1.

GREEN LANTERN VERSES ALIENS (2000)
Collected in Dark Horse Comics/DC Comics: Justice League Vol. 2.

JLA VS PREDATOR (2001)
Collected in Dark Horse Comics/DC Comics: Justice League Vol. 2.

SUPERMAN/ALIENS 2: GOD WAR (2002)
Collected in Dark Horse Comics/DC Comics: Superman.

BATMAN/ALIENS II (2002)
Collected in DC Comics/Dark Horse Comics: Aliens.

SUPERMAN AND BATMAN VS ALIENS AND PREDATOR (2007)
Collected in DC Comics/Dark Horse Comics: Aliens.

NOTE ABOUT THE COLLECTIONS

The above collections contain a LOT of other material, from Superman battling Terminators to Batman teaming up with Tarzan to a really weird crossover between Batgirl and Ghost that, as a story, was hard for me to follow. Some of them are good, some are not as good, but all of them have their audience.

The most interesting of the bunch, and most relevant here, is the WILDCats vs. Aliens story that I’m not including here because when it was created the characters were not part of the DC Universe, but this crossover, when it occurred, had lasting effects in the actual WILDCats storyline. Characters were killed off by the xenomorphs and STAYED dead afterward in their regular series. (The same was true for the Madman/Superman crossover, in that there were lasting effects in the Madman series after the crossover.)

Did you like this article? Share it with your friends!

Tweet

Written by BenAvery

Visit my Website

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • iTunes
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • About
  • Podcast
  • Support
    • Amazon
    • My Comic Shop
  • Other Podcasts

Recent Posts

  • “Master Assassin of Mars” Parts 7-9 (John Carter, Warlord of Mars 21, 22, & 23) – MCC123/CBTM183
  • Marvel Comics Blind Bag from Wal-Mart (Ben) – CBTM182
  • WEREWOLF BY NIGHT on Disney+ – SWAMP THINGS Ep. 22
  • WEREWOLF BY NIGHT on Disney+ (Ben) – CBTM181
  • “Warriors Three” (Shogun Warriors #2, March 1979) – MCC122/CBTM180

Tags

2001: A Space Odyssey Action Comics Archie Goodwin Avengers Batman Ben Reilly Bill Mantlo Cabal Carmine Infantino Crisis on Infinite Earths dc comics DC Universe Rebirth Devil Dinosaur Doug Moench fantastic four Godzilla Green Lantern Herb Trimpe Howard Chaykin Human Fly Illuminati Jack Kirby John Carter John Carter: Warlord of Mars Jonathan Hickman justice league Logan's Run Machine Man Man from Atlantis Manhunter Mark Shaw Marvel Marv Wolfman New Avengers Rebirth Roy Thomas secret wars Silver Surfer Spider-Man spider-verse Star Wars superman Time Runs Out ultimate marvel What If

Archives

  • December 2022
  • October 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • November 2019
  • August 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • January 2019
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • December 2015
  • November 2015
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014
  • July 2014
  • May 2014

Categories

  • 2001: A Space Odyssey
  • Battlestar Galactica
  • Ben
  • Ben's Bullpen Bulletin
  • Between Disney
  • Comics
  • Crazy Magazine
  • Crisis on Infinite Earths
  • Crossover
  • Daniel
  • DC Rebirth
  • Events
  • Featured
  • Godzilla: King of the Monsters
  • Grab Bag
  • Group Episodes
  • Human Fly
  • John Carter: Warlord of Mars
  • Journey into the Mysterious House of Terror's Vault of Astonishing Suspense
  • Justice League: Gods and Monsters
  • Logan's Run
  • Man from Atlantis
  • Marvel Classics Comics
  • Marvel Movie Specials
  • Marvel Sci-Fi
  • Marvel Sci-Fi and Fantasy
  • Marvel Super Special
  • Marvel Team-Up
  • Matt
  • New Star Wars
  • October Horror Comics
  • Podcast
  • Review
  • Secret Wars
  • Shogun Warriors
  • Spider-Man
  • Spider-Verse
  • Star Wars
  • Swamp Things
  • The Micronauts
  • The What If Challenge
  • Uncategorized
  • Week of Weird
  • What If? & Elseworlds
  • What If/Elseworlds

Recent Comments

  • GHOSTS #46: A Flea Market Challenge (Ben) – CBTM176 – The Comic Book Time Machine on GHOSTLY HAUNTS #31: Flea Market Challnge Pt. 2 – SWAMP THINGS Ep. 21/CBTM 177
  • GHOSTLY HAUNTS #31: Flea Market Challnge Pt. 2 – SWAMP THINGS Ep. 21/CBTM 177 – The Comic Book Time Machine on GHOSTS #46: A Flea Market Challenge (Ben) – CBTM176
  • GHOSTLY HAUNTS #31: Flea Market Challnge Pt. 2 – SWAMP THINGS Ep. 21/CBTM 177 – The Comic Book Time Machine on MAN-THING’S ORIGINS (Savage Tales #1 and Astonishing Tales #12 and 13) Swamp Things Ep. 2 – CBTM103
  • GHOSTS #46: A Flea Market Challenge – CBTM176 (Ben) – The Comic Book Time Machine on MAN-THING’S ORIGINS (Savage Tales #1 and Astonishing Tales #12 and 13) Swamp Things Ep. 2 – CBTM103
  • Wal-Mart’s WW84 Blind Bag – CBTM165 – The Comic Book Time Machine on DC Four-Packs at Wal-Mart (Ben) – CBTM160

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
  • iTunes
  • RSS

Marvel’s Cosmic Comics

“Master Assassin of Mars” Parts 7-9 (John Carter, Warlord of Mars 21, 22, & 23) – MCC123/CBTM183
“Master Assassin of Mars” Parts 7-9 (John Carter, Warlord of Mars 21, 22, & 23) – MCC123/CBTM183

Using Star Wars as a guideline,  we’re exploring comic books based on licensed properties that Marvel Comics published from 1977 to 1986. For this episode, Ben reads the next three chapters in the 12 issue epic “Master Assassin of Mars” from JOHN CARTER issues 21-23, December 1978, January 1979, and February … [...]

“Warriors Three” (Shogun Warriors #2, March 1979) – MCC122/CBTM180
“Warriors Three” (Shogun Warriors #2, March 1979) – MCC122/CBTM180

Using Star Wars as a guideline,  we’re exploring comic books based on licensed properties that Marvel Comics published from 1977 to 1986. Ben returns to 1979 to read the toy-line tie-in SHOGUN WARRIORS! Last issue introduced three pilots and one robot . . . but this issue brings two more robots … [...]

“Highwire to Heaven” (Re-Upload) (Human Fly #19, March 1979) MCC121/CBTM174
“Highwire to Heaven” (Re-Upload) (Human Fly #19, March 1979) MCC121/CBTM174

(We have moved our websites to a new server, and as a result we lost this post, meaning I had to re-upload it. Please accept our apologies if you had this show up in your feed twice. Thank you!) Using Star Wars as a guideline,  we’re exploring comic books based on … [...]

“Annihilation” (Battlestar Galactica #1) – MCC120/CBTM171
“Annihilation” (Battlestar Galactica #1) – MCC120/CBTM171

Using Star Wars as a guideline,  we’re exploring comic books based on licensed properties that Marvel Comics published from 1977 to 1986. And we’re beginning the journey to find a lonely plant . . . known as . . . EARTH! So excited! Battlestar Galactica was absolutely the product of a … [...]

“Shadow of a Dark Lord” (Star Wars #21, March 1979) – MCC119 and CBTM162
“Shadow of a Dark Lord” (Star Wars #21, March 1979) – MCC119 and CBTM162

Using Star Wars as a guideline,  we’re exploring comic books based on licensed properties that Marvel Comics published from 1977 to 1986. Star Wars continues! Luke faces Vader . . . in a hallucination! Han Solo faces Chewy . . . in a zero-G arena! Leia faces stormtroopers . . . … [...]

“The Lady and the Lion!” (John Carter: Warlord of Mars #21, February 1979) – MCC118 and CBTM152
“The Lady and the Lion!” (John Carter: Warlord of Mars #21, February 1979) – MCC118 and CBTM152

Using Star Wars as a guideline,  we’re exploring comic books based on licensed properties that Marvel Comics published from 1977 to 1986. The Master Assassin of Mars continues . . . with gladiatorial combat in an arena against a very big lion with a large number of legs. And teeth. But … [...]

“Earth!” (Micronauts #2, Feb 1979) – MCC117 and CBTM151
“Earth!” (Micronauts #2, Feb 1979) – MCC117 and CBTM151

The Micronauts move from inner space to yard space as they take on one of the great dangers of the back yard - a lawn mower! [...]

“A Gathering of Vultures” (Human Fly #19, Feb 1979) – MCC116
“A Gathering of Vultures” (Human Fly #19, Feb 1979) – MCC116

The Human Fly travels to his next stunt location and find some real world issues that need to be taken care of, REAL-LIFE SUPERHERO STYLE! [...]

“With Dugan on the Docks” (Godzilla #19, February 1979) – MCC115
“With Dugan on the Docks” (Godzilla #19, February 1979) – MCC115

Godzilla, now man-sized, sneaks through the city . . . until he comes to a face-off with Dum Dum Dugan. A face-off that finally allows Dum Dum and Big-G to come face to face and go mano-a-mano! [...]

“Raydeen” (Shogun Warriors #1, February 1979) – MCC114
“Raydeen” (Shogun Warriors #1, February 1979) – MCC114

Shogun Warriors, a Doug Moench and Herb Trimpe work based on the Mattel toyline that merged a number of Japanese properties into one, gets its origin in this "1st ISSUE COLLECTOR'S ITEM"! And the license seems to be in good hands!  [...]

“Deathgame” (Star Wars #20, February 1979) – MCC113
“Deathgame” (Star Wars #20, February 1979) – MCC113

"Deathgame" continues Archie Goodwin's original Star Wars tale taking place on The Wheel, a space casino that puts everyone in danger! And the stakes just keep on rising! In a world where Empire Strikes Back was still only in script form, the Star Wars universe grew here! [...]

Battlestar Galactica Marvel Super Special! (Ben’s Bullpen Bulletin, January 1979) – MCC112
Battlestar Galactica Marvel Super Special! (Ben’s Bullpen Bulletin, January 1979) – MCC112

The coverage of Marvel’s licensed books from January 1979 ends here as we take a peek at the ads and company promo items from this month and then take a look at the treasury sized edition of Marvel’s adaptation of Battlestar Galactica in Marvel Super Special #8! [...]

“Battle at the Bottom of the World” (John Carter, Warlord of Mars #20, January 1979) – MCC111
“Battle at the Bottom of the World” (John Carter, Warlord of Mars #20, January 1979) – MCC111

The fifth chapter in Chris Claremont's "Master Assassin of Mars" continues here as John Carter fights a war for the very people who are making it so he cannot leave their underground world. But he plans to leave and he's taking Dejah Thoris with him...if only he can rescue her! [...]

“Fugitive in Manhattan” (Godzilla #18, January 1979) – MCC110
“Fugitive in Manhattan” (Godzilla #18, January 1979) – MCC110

Godzilla is shrunk down to the size of a house cat but he's still the king of the monsters! King of the TINY monsters, but king none-the-less. [...]

Micronauts! (The Micronauts #1, January 1979) – MCC109
Micronauts! (The Micronauts #1, January 1979) – MCC109

Bill Mantlo's classic run begins here! A toy line with no story is transformed into an inner-space opera epic starting with this issue: The Micronauts #1! [...]

“Photo Finish” (The Human Fly #17, January 1979) – MCC108
“Photo Finish” (The Human Fly #17, January 1979) – MCC108

The theft of a little girl's camera reveals an attempt to sabotage the Human Fly's newest stunt! But what reason do the criminals have to do this? And why is the Fly going through with it? More important: is the story any good? [...]

“The Ultimate Gamble” (Star Wars #19, January 1979) – MCC107
“The Ultimate Gamble” (Star Wars #19, January 1979) – MCC107

The death wheel in the sky keeps on turning and our team doesn't know where they'll be tomorrow! Today, however, they know they're in danger from both the Empire and the people of the space station they found themselves on, which was supposed to be a safe haven! [...]

Devil Dinosaur and Machine Man Finales! (Ben’s Bullpen Bulletin, December 1978) – MCC106
Devil Dinosaur and Machine Man Finales! (Ben’s Bullpen Bulletin, December 1978) – MCC106

Taking a look at some of the extra things going on when the comics cover dated December of 1978 were on the stands . . . like the final issues of Devil Dinosaur and Machine Man. And the FIRST issue of a new series that will be covered in our next round of Marvel's Cosmic Comics! [...]

“The Valiant Die But Once” (John Carter: Warlord of Mars #19, November 1978) – MCC105
“The Valiant Die But Once” (John Carter: Warlord of Mars #19, November 1978) – MCC105

Trapped in a strange land, John Carter and Dejah Thoris find their bonds of love tested and perhaps found lacking! John carter and a new friend also find their battle skills put to the test in a seemingly endless wave of savages! [...]

JAWS 2 (Marvel Super Special #6) – MCC104
JAWS 2 (Marvel Super Special #6) – MCC104

"Just when you thought it was safe to go back in the water..." they go and make a sequel! [...]

© 2023 The Comic Book Time Machine

Powered by Esplanade Theme and WordPress